• Home
  • About

Penny's Bookshelf

The world was hers for the reading

  • Book Aesthetics
  • Book Essentials
  • Book Lists
  • Book Reviews
  • Bookish Travel

September 28, 2026

The Woman in the Library by Sulari Gentill Review

best crime thriller

This crime thriller had me guessing all the way to the end! I’m so glad I finally picked this one up because it did not disappoint!

Publisher Synopsis

USA TODAY BESTSELLER * MARY HIGGINS CLARK AWARD NOMINEE * 2022 BOOKPAGE BEST MYSTERIES AND SUSPENSE * LIBRARY READS TOP 10 BOOKS OF 2022 * CRIME READS BEST NEW CRIME FICTION

“Investigations are launched, fingers are pointed, potentially dangerous liaisons unfold and I was turning those pages like there was cake at the finish line.” –Moira Macdonald, Seattle Times must-read books for summer 2022

Ned Kelly award winning author Sulari Gentill sets this mystery-within-a-mystery in motion with a deceptively simple, Dear Hannah, What are you writing? pulling us into the ornate reading room at the Boston Public Library.

In every person’s story, there is something to hide…

The tranquility is shattered by a woman’s terrified scream. Security guards take charge immediately, instructing everyone inside to stay put until the threat is identified and contained. While they wait for the all-clear, four strangers, who’d happened to sit at the same table, pass the time in conversation and friendships are struck. Each has his or her own reasons for being in the reading room that morning–it just happens that one is a murderer.

Sulari Gentill delivers a sharply thrilling read with The Woman in the Library, an unexpectedly twisty literary adventure that examines the complicated nature of friendship and shows us that words can be the most treacherous weapons of all.

Title Information

Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press
Release Date: June 07, 2022
Pages: 288
Series: No
Genres: Fiction, Mystery, Murder Mystery, Thrillers – Crime, Thrillers – Suspense, Popular Fiction

My Review

This was my first thriller for the fall season and it did not disappoint. This fast-paced, multi-award winning crime thriller has sat on my TBR shelf for far too long. It was one of those books that I picked out right after it was published and that I had every intention of reading immediately, but my mood never matched the book until now. I recently came across this idea of having an antilibrary which consists of books that you have yet to read. The idea is that you will pick up the right book at the exact right time that you need them the most. I thought it was such a beautiful sentiment and I will adopt any excuse to romanticize my TBR. Turns out that now was the best time for me to read this genius murder mystery that had me thinking about it long after I turned the last page.

Woman in the Library begins as a right place, wrong time chance meeting of strangers. As their friendship develops, this odd pairing of people simultaneously add comedic relief and a creeping sense of unease which is exactly what I wanted in this crime thriller. I really enjoyed the layering of narratives which I think added so much to the overall tension of the plot. You’re reading along and becoming immersed in the first plot and then all the sudden you’re not sure anymore which storyline you’re actually in. Sulari’s breadcrumb trail is so subtle that I had no idea who the murderer was until the very end! The misdirection away from the true murderer was genius in its execution. While the characters develop throughout the novel, they develop at a slow pace which allows the reader to stay immersed in the “whodunit” theme of the plot. This isn’t a mystery that gives you all the answers up front starting with the body and working your way back to the murder. This crime thriller unravels with each turn of the page. A perfect read for a travel day or a rainy weekend, you’ll be sure to have a hard time putting this one down.

Buy it Here!
Bookshop.org

Posted In: Book Reviews, Uncategorized · Tagged: crime thriller, murder mystery

Get on the List

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hello! I’m Elena, but you can call me Penny

About Me
I'm a blogger, freelance editor, and voracious reader. When I'm not traversing new worlds in pages, you can find me chasing my children and pets all around my garden.

Categories

  • Book Essentials
  • Book Lists
  • Book Reviews
  • Uncategorized

Reader Favorites

Best-Cozy-Fantasy

The Best Cozy Fantasy Review

dark-academia

9 Dark Academia New Releases Perfect for Fall

dark romance read

A Popular Dark Romance Review

Connect

pennysbookshelfblog

Bibliophile 📚 Freelance Editor & Book Blogger

@offcampusonprime hangover means an ignored TBR so @offcampusonprime hangover means an ignored TBR so I can make this series my entire personality 😂
Newborn reading days ❤️❤️ Newborn reading days ❤️❤️
The world was hers for the reading📚 MPS in Publish The world was hers for the reading📚 MPS in Publishing
Thanks @netgalley for the early access! I can’t wa Thanks @netgalley for the early access! I can’t wait to review this one!
I wish I could read this series all over again! It I wish I could read this series all over again! It’s by far my favorite cozy fantasy of the year and I am kicking myself for letting it sit on my TBR for wayyy too long! If you are looking for your next great cozy fantasy read, I beg you to pick up this one. My first spoiler free review is up on the new blog tomorrow morning!
At @rojocoffeeco for a research morning ❤️ At @rojocoffeeco for a research morning ❤️
I’ve been devouring Ali Hazelwoods books recently I’ve been devouring Ali Hazelwoods books recently and it’s posed me off to NO END that she has gotten bullied off social media for a character preference!? This woman writes books about smart women, women with agency, women who push back against gender stereotypes and aren’t afraid to take up space. There are authors still publishing books with racist comments and pushing dangerous gender ideals in romantic relationships and deserve to be pushed off this platform. Beyond disappointed in this book community rn. If you haven’t read an Ali Hazelwood, literally any one of them, pick it up and read it, because they are all amazing and she should be celebrated for her genius!
Just finished! Loved, loved, loved returning to th Just finished! Loved, loved, loved returning to the world of demons with the mouthy and bold Genevieve! Sibling rivalry and a fake marriage for survival, this is a must read!
About to devour this book! Can’t wait to cry with About to devour this book! Can’t wait to cry with the rest of the bookstagram community. @rebeccayarros
An ambitious fall TBR😅 I went shopping on my own s An ambitious fall TBR😅 I went shopping on my own shelves this morning, how *very mindful* of me.
Essentially, these are all the books I’ll be reading alongside the Stormlight Archive Series since I have a problem just reading one book at a time🫠 
#falltbr #brandonsanderson #moodreader #readersofinstagram
An article about books, tea, and a covered porch i An article about books, tea, and a covered porch in the rain in the middle of nowhere. Perfection 🖤 #mastersstudent #publishing #cpsgwu
Bachelors of Arts English Literature ❤️❤️ What a r Bachelors of Arts English Literature ❤️❤️ What a road
Graduate school here we come 🙏🏼🥹❤️ Graduate school here we come 🙏🏼🥹❤️
Tomorrow I start my first day of internship in pub Tomorrow I start my first day of internship in publishing 😍🥹 to say in excited is an understatement. Also really enjoying this textbook for my creative writing summer course.
Another semester of English Literature 🥰🥰🥰🥰 and ma Another semester of English Literature 🥰🥰🥰🥰 and many early morning reads on night shift
Having a bit of an unhual today and hunting for th Having a bit of an unhual today and hunting for the required texts for this new semester 🥰 I just bought the black cover in paperback of ACOSF so don’t @ me because I would never #unhaul #englishstudent @bookexchangevb
A STUNNING AND VENGEFUL READ! I rooted for this pr A STUNNING AND VENGEFUL READ! I rooted for this protagonist at every dark turn and especially when her rage overcame her. A must read.
I will forever be jealous of everyone reading this I will forever be jealous of everyone reading this for the first time.
Reading goal for the 4 day weekend complete! What Reading goal for the 4 day weekend complete! What a cliffhanger to end on too! Rainbow Rowell 💋💋chefs kiss! Wayward Son was everything I didn’t know I wanted
Late night reads Late night reads
Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2026 Penny's Bookshelf · Theme by 17th Avenue